Is Bonfire Night being eclipsed by Halloween?

Posted on November 9th, 2018

Bonfire night feels like it is steadily being eclipsed by Halloween. Certainly here we make a big event out of our Halloween fun Day, yet our once legendary Bonfire night celebrations have lapsed. It is partly a result of timing. Bonfire night used to fall in half term, yet now always falls the week after when we are quiet. Furthermore, our own kids have grown up and are now seeking out the big organised events with their friends rather than hot dogs, bonfire and fireworks here on the farm.

 

Is Bonfire night being eclipsed by Halloween

Safety Concerns

I do wonder if safety is a factor, especially for the DIY garden bonfire night celebrations.  I always worry when Farmer Nick is putting on our wonderful events, though he has become an expert over the years. Pumpkin decorating, baking and even supervised Trick or Treat feels a safer option. 

Financial implications

I feel this could be a big factor. Our fireworks for Guy Fawkes night were costing upwards of £200.  Halloween costs are far less, even with a whole day of fun planned.

A shift in tradition

Pumpkin patches are popping up everywhere; a visit now feels almost an obligation, but what happened to  ‘A Penny for the Guy’? Does this still happen anywhere?

St Tudy Village Bonfire and Fireworks Night

When November the 5th rolled round this year and we were faced with a clear still night and a balmy 14 degrees we headed into our local village of St Tudy to join their annual celebrations. What a treat it was. The playing fields were full of children, sparklers, vans selling hot dogs, Cornish pasties and even a licensed bar. Our kids disappeared in seconds having found old school friends while we caught up with their parents. It is all organised by the village carnival committee and run simply on donations in a bucket on the gate. All I can say is it must have taken plenty of cake sales and pub quizzes to raise enough to put on the amazing display we enjoyed. The bonfire crackled and the fireworks wowed. We had a wonderful evening with no planning, no responsibility and £200 up on the night vs running our own! 

For anyone staying with us on November 5th Next year, I can totally recommend this as a cheap local attraction not to be missed.

Kids sparklers swirl watching the bonfire burn

sparklers watching the bonfire

A fizz and a bang as the night sky lights up

Fireworks at St Tudy

Heads crane up to the sky, little ones in arms and on shoulders in awe  

Bonfire Night fun at St Tudy Cornwall

A solitary burst in a magnificent display

Firework at St Tudy Bonfire Night

 

Is Bonfire night being eclipsed by Halloween?

To come back to my original question: Is Bonfire Night being eclipsed by Halloween, I think perhaps it is more a shift, Halloween is more home led family activities while Bonfire night is becoming big organised events.  Halloween feels more significant now as the associated activities and newly forming traditions keep growing over a longer period. Bonfire night is more of a short sharp ‘big bang’, but still a memorable event that I hope survives for generations to come.